Muni Arts Centre, Pontypridd
1st November 2009
In the genre of music that those of us who visit this website love, it’s pretty obvious to me that the scene is underpinned by a series of bands who have had lengthy careers, studded with many classic albums. Just a browse through this site reveals many many references to the likes of Iron Maiden and UFO. Magnum can fall into this category too. For years Tony Clarkin has managed to pen gems such as Les Morts Dansant and Don’t Wake the Lion.
Both those were in the set list last night in Pontypridd, but they were conspicuous in a running order that was drawn almost exclusively from their last three albums. Here lies Magnum’s difficulty; I’m the first to complain when a band keeps the same set list year after year and for a while (albeit with variations thanks to tours celebrating the release of classic albums On a Storyteller’s Night and Wings of Heaven respectively) Magnum have probably been guilty of that.
Tony Clarkin, however, is not a man to rest on his laurels. His reason given for splitting Magnum in the mid 90s was that he was fed up of playing ‘Kingdom of Madness’ over and over again. Ironically that track made an appearance as last song of the encore, sending the punters home smiling. By removing most of the ‘classic’ songs such as ‘Sacred Hour’ and ‘How Far Jerusalem’, Clarkin has shown he doesn’t want Magnum to just end up being a nostalgia act. He’s making a statement that here is a band that’s still vibrant and viable in the present day. The easy way forward would be to take the shilling, play the classics, go down the road of the Sweet or ELO.
One of the advantages of refreshing the set was that the band seemed to be more engaged than on some recent tours. There have been times recently when I’ve seen a great, fantastic live act seem to go through the motions on occasion. Here, we had Clarkin looking healthier than he has done for years, and Bob Catley defying the onset of time to deliver his usual impeccable vocal performance. Is there another singer of his generation with the confidence to still take on his entire vocal range in a live setting? Mark Stanway had a smile on his face all night, and Al Barrow delivered some tasteful harmony vocals in addition to his usual solid bass playing.
So why do I feel ever so slightly uncomfortable with the gig?
Unfortunately, what it proved to me is that the older songs are what goes into making Magnum Magnum. That’s not to say that the new material is bad, but when sat next to the swaggering pomposity of ‘Les Morts Dansant’ the newer songs seem a little forced, like they are trying to imitate the classics of yesteryear without quite reaching the same peak. As ‘Don’t Wake the Lion’ builds to its crescendo, it does so with a certain inevitability, it’s a path well trod and a path that allows the song to flow as a seamless whole. The newer songs seem, in contrast, to be a little contrived, an attempt to replicate past glories yet slightly missing out; there’s no melodrama in the choruses in the same way that ‘Vigilante’ thunders from the amps, grabbing you by the throat and forcing you to engage.
So I find myself asking for that which I complained about earlier, more old songs.
Yet here is a band with a huge back catalogue. Albums such as The Eleventh Hour are hidden gems that have been sorely neglected for years. It’s not like Clarkin has to throw the baby out with the bathwater if Magnum are to revise their set list, there are plenty of ‘classic’ songs that haven’t received an airing for years. Throw in a couple of the newer songs by all means, but don’t neglect what went into making the band what it is today. Keep it vibrant, refresh the songs played, but bear in mind the band’s heritage. The energy that flows from both band and audience is ratcheted up to a level few bands can match when it comes to the older tracks. Without them the gig remains a good gig, but not a memorable gig.
I have to finish off with a final thought however; are my views coloured because I’m a fan? Am I biased because I remember their last ever gig before they split in the 90s? That is still the best gig I’ve ever been to; there was a band on fire belting out track after track, determined to go out on a high, willed on by an audience there to worship and pay homage to their heroes. How can they ever match that?
Perhaps they can’t, and perhaps that’s the problem. Perhaps without those memories I would appreciate what I have so much more. And yet my friend had no knowledge of the band, and his view of the gig was that, well, it was alright but all a bit one-paced.
He liked ‘Don’t Wake the Lion’ though, one of their classic songs; but he didn’t know it was a classic song until I told him. He did know it was a league above the newer tracks though, just by listening to it.
—–
BE
Return To Main Page
New Section
Posted in Comments, Music on November 8, 2009 by rockofagesRock Of Ages has never been a site about regurgitating Press Releases readily available elsewhere so that it looks like I’m posting something new regularly, and we’ve stuck steadfastly to the practice of finishing our reviews with a mark out of 5 rather than follow the worrying trend of numerous magazines and sites and steering away from offering a rating for fear of upsetting the PR people and cutting off the supply of promos. However, I hope you’ll forgive me the pleasure of introducing a new section where I get a bit “promotional” and attempt to blow my own trumpet a bit!
I’ve been fortunate over the past few months to get pitch some reissue ideas to a record company and in partnership with Lyadrive frontman, long time music industry exec and occasional Rock Of Ages contributor Nicholas John have seen some of those come to fruition… or at least the first one gets released tomorrow (with more to follow hopefully)!
If I could be so rude then to draw your attention to the “Sleeve Notes” section added to the right hand “Contents” list… you will find details not only of the release - “LITTLE ANGELS” classic debut album “Don’t Prey For Me” – but details of other projects I’ve had some involvement in, information on the extent of my involvement and if wordpress continue to allow it, links to where you can buy the discs.
Advert over…
many thanks
Bill
3 Comments »